posted in Technology
I don't like passkeys | Ethan Hawksley
hawksley.dev/blog/i-dont-like-passkeysReplying to @lemmydividebyzero@reddthat.com
I feel like there’s some potential in password-derived passkeys, which would get around the storage and hardware lock-in issues. It’d essentially be a master password like for BitWarden, but instead of needing an app to store a bunch of generated passwords, the master password could be all you need to authenticate.
Most of the sources of compromise for regular users would be eliminated because the password never leaves the client.
Replying to @Technus@lemmy.zip
The return of SASL DIGEST! (Or these days probably CRAM or SCRAM)
But yeah, the “hard” part would be that you don’t want the user to type in a password to the website because it could get snatched, so you’d want the User Agent to pop up a password prompt, you type it, and then it does the hashing etc internally and only dumps the hash into the request. So you’d still need some kind of standard for that.
Which is basically just HTTP auth from the 90s. So the good news is that’s always been possible, and already has broad support and works with all browsers! 😛