I'm in a somewhat awkward position - but since it's about security, and the only way to (hopefully) reach all Sharkey admins and bring this to their attention is by making a public post, I'll do just that.

You probably know that Sharkey is now based on a Misskey version that is 18 months old - falling behind is very understandable, especially for a long standing fork. But since almost 500 fediverse servers are running on Sharkey (495 according to fedidb), at least security releases are essential.

So I have to let you know that we have now notified the Sharkey devs twice about several upstream vulnerabilities we found (and fixed) in Catodon, with the first time being over a month ago. The latest stable Sharkey release was almost 5 months ago, which means they have yet to be patched in a stable release. In the meantime Misskey has also released security fixes, which have also not landed in a stable release yet.

This is not an attack on Sharkey, I hope this comes as a wakeup call, because Sharkey has truly been a great platform. But the hundreds of Sharkey admins (and users) should know about the unpatched vulnerabilities the software currently carries.

#sharkey #sharkeyadmin #misskey #fediverse

Catodon rocksCatodon rocksOfficial server of the Catodon project - home of Catodon development. Things may occasionally break when we test new features. Everyone is welcome except fascists, racists, sexists, bigots and cops. No harassment, no hate speech. Be nice. Destroy capitalism.

Replying to @⁨panos@catodon.rocks⁩

@panos@catodon.rocks

When I migrated my server away from Firefish, I chose Sharkey as I thought it would be a progressive and exciting alternative on the Fediverse.

Initially there were some new features but that has stalled, and we only seem to get occasional emergency security updates (most recent 4 months ago).

Such as shame.

Also:

You can add one to the 495 counted on FediDB. For Whatever reason my server is not on it, and never has been. Even if I add manually or contact the dev (Who completely ignores me). I have no idea why. It's not like I am new. This server is 3.5 years old!

Replying to @⁨bumble@ibe.social⁩

@bumble@ibe.social yeah, when Firefish died I had high hopes for Iceshrimp, but was also disappointed by that project for several reasons. I'm glad I finally run my own project and I can be serious about it, but I know that it will be hard to gain trust after all that has happened with Misskey forks in the past. Catodon's first attempt also didn't help, since it was abandoned by the lead dev at the time too. Will take time to prove that things are truly different this time, but I'm fine with that.