Replying to @⁨deeprlyeh@lemmus.org⁩

These folks don’t actually wanna leave. Peter Thiel will blow a lot of smoke about how he’s totally gonna leave California because of Communisim or whatever, but there’s a couple things to keep in mind.

  1. The billionaires are spending mad money to fight this tax. This is not the action of someone who plans to leave the state.

  2. The infrastructure that makes the billionaires rich cannot be moved from California easily. A person is easy to move, a warehouse less so. Those assets can be taxed, even if the owner leaves the state.

  3. Fuck these guys. Billionaires do not contribute to the economy; they suck out the wealth and hoard it. Even in the worst case scenario of rich folks leaving the state with their ill gotten gains, the state wasn’t gonna get that money anyways The worst case scenario for California of the mythical “Wealth Flight” is a bunch of parasites moving elsewhere.

These parasites have had it too good for too long. A measly little one time tax is a step in the right direction that I hope opens the door to more aggressive taxation on these dregs of society.

Replying to an earlier post

The billionaires are spending mad money to fight this tax.

Mad for regular people money. From what I’ve read, what they’ve spent is a small fraction of what said tax would cost them (though if you’ve seen different, I love new info!)

A person is easy to move, a warehouse less so.

These folks don’t usually have warehouses, but whatever, say physical infrastructure. All that can stay, the boss can roll out, rock in Texas and take their private jet to and fro as needed. (Or, do their stuff remotely. I doubt Thiel is walking through cubicles etc.)

The worst case scenario for California of the mythical “Wealth Flight” is a bunch of parasites moving elsewhere.

The worst case is that the tax revenue that those billionaires bring (which sure, in a moral vacuum should probably be higher) goes elsewhere leaving California needing to plug the fiscal gap by taxing less wealthy folks or eliminating/reducing services.

Replying to @⁨MyBrainHurts@piefed.ca⁩

The average tax income from billionaires in california looks to be around 10million a year. So combined the about 200 billionaires in california are paying 2 billion a year. Rough numbers would be that is 150 of them left then the one time tax would start being a negative income in 10 years. That assumes money stays flat.

Honestly there is no way that this ends up being a serious net negative and these folks are still operating in California enough that they may fail to avoid residency review.

Replying to an earlier post

Estimates seem to vary but I’ve found a good few at 3 billion total from the wealthiest 200 Californians.

Also, given the article noted that:

Departing billionaires slashed projected one-time revenue from $100 billion to $40 billion, with Page and Brin’s exits alone costing California $26.7 billion.

That implies the current tax revenue from billionaires would drop 60 or so percent. So, presumably tax revenue drops from 3 to 1.2 billion, just based on current flights (and ignoring knock on effects.)

So, no one else leaves and we don’t count knock on effects, I’d guess it’d take ~ 21 or so years before this starts cutting. But, of course, knock on effects (folks decamp to say, Texas which seems to be snagging as many once Californian businesses as possible…) It’s going to be a very interesting, depressing experiment. (Really feels like a race to the bottom but that’s the America we know and,uhhh, love?)

Replying to @⁨johntash@eviltoast.org⁩

excuse me most of their worth isn’t going to be liquid because they made it illiquid by design and every incentive to pump their own assets we are asking for real valuation if they want to avoid taxation. meaning the stock market housing market all bubbles will be much more muted if they dont wanna pay the taxes. the whole reason for the extreme bubbles in housing is precisely for the buy hold die strategy while paying almost no taxes and instead use the borrowed money to buy up everything and enslave multiple generations with borrowed money off hot air balloon money.

either they can sell covered calls on their own stock sell their stock or dividends. or they can take out loans on the stock or take out loans on their house or rent it out for extra income i dont care they have millions and billions in value so go tap it and pay the tax if you dont wanna pay as much tax lower the valuation or extract value from it to pay the tax no one cares.

Replying to @⁨ChicoSuave@lemmy.world⁩

thing is the closest easiest tax to implement that would target the elite networth is the land value tax not wealth tax because they cannot move land. it literally is right there cannot be hidden. they may argue about the value but they cannot escape. its the least bad tax as well. but homeowners keep on complaining like little girls that boomers cant pay for it except boomers have already been bailed out by 2-3 generations already they stole futures from and now they still complain whine moan while voting for nimby policies they are literally destroying multiple generations putting them and us all into slavery for their own gain because they are the most spoiled brat generation to have ever walked the earth.

so sick of it. just tax them until they all go bankrupt. 20% lvt will cover income tax and sales tax for the whole country