FEP-fc48: Generic ActivityPub server

This is a discussion thread for FEP-fc48: Generic ActivityPub server.

Summary

Generic ActivityPub server is a server that implements standard ActivityPub client API or FEP-ae97 client API, and can process any activity (including activities those behavior is not defined in the ActivityPub specification).

Summary card of repository fediverse/fep, described as: Fediverse Enhancement ProposalsCodeberg.orgfep/fep/fc48/fep-fc48.md at mainfep - Fediverse Enhancement Proposals

Replying to @⁨silverpill@socialhub.activitypub.rocks⁩

Update: https://codeberg.org/fediverse/fep/pulls/851

I think the FEP now better explains why side effects must be explicit:

A generic server can only carry out the side effects of basic activities. Therefore, clients MUST specify the side effects of all other activities as additional activities. Clients can embed them into an activity using the result property, or send them separately.

Replying to an earlier post

Is there more than the list of 5 basic activities that can be considered generic, I wonder? Perhaps it might make sense to describe what a generic server supports, in the form of Use Cases, in a similar way as the motivational use cases in the ActivityStreams vocubulary spec. Then for each use case a consistent pattern can be specified that MUST be implemented (either refer to AP spec if robustly defined there and/or add additional info on format, behavior, msg exchange).

www.w3.orgActivity Vocabulary