posted in Technology
DHS Inspector General Finds That TSA is Not Properly Safeguarding Passenger Facial Recognition Data
www.eff.org/deeplinks/2026/10/dhs-inspector-general-finds-tsa-not-properly-safeguarding-passenger-facialposted in Technology
DHS Inspector General Finds That TSA is Not Properly Safeguarding Passenger Facial Recognition Data
www.eff.org/deeplinks/2026/10/dhs-inspector-general-finds-tsa-not-properly-safeguarding-passenger-facialReplying to @NightOwl@lemmy.ca
If you are at a US airport, you will be made to feel like you need to scan your face. The TSA agent will say, “look at the camera” like there’s no choice. You don’t need to. Always just say “opt-out.” That’s all you need to do.
They will check your ID and use their eyeballs to compare it to your face, taking all of 10 extra seconds, and safeguarding your privacy a little bit more.
These types of security issues are inevitable, and the only way to win this game is to not play.
From the article:
Reminder: Opting Out of TSA Photos Is Possible Given that facial recognition technology is prone to mistakes, combined with the OIG’s audit revealing significant privacy weaknesses, it is imperative that travelers remember that opting out is possible. TSA’s own website emphasizes that travelers who wish to decline to have their photo taken for facial comparison can do so without any delay, disruption, or recourse.
Replying to @NekoKoneko@lemmy.world
I opt out every time and without fail get “randomly” selected for additional screening, for this I always give them double birds during the additional screening.
Replying to @diablomnky@lemmy.world
I fuck with airport security screens as much as possible. My latest is to show up an hour early with a couple of butter knives I ‘borrowed’ from previous flights. I have a collection from airlines from around the world so I match my upcoming carrier when I can. Watching those apes struggle to verify if my completely blunt, clearly approved butter knives are somehow restricted is worth the lost time.
My favorite is when they claim they’re forbidden and I get to pose the obvious objection: if they’re restricted due to posing a safety hazard, why is it acceptable that I’ll get one anyhow on my upcoming flight? How is that identical butter knife safer?
Replying to @diablomnky@lemmy.world
I opt out every time and have never gotten randomly selected for additional screening. Maybe you’re getting profiled in another way?
Replying to @qqq@lemmy.world
Possibly, although I doubt it. I’m your average white guy with pre-check using a Global Entry ID. So I got all their extra vetting done and I suspect this is just harassment for knowing my rights.
Replying to @NekoKoneko@lemmy.world
Not every country lets you opt out though unfortunately, so you’re fucked no matter what.
Replying to @Fredthefishlord@lemmy.blahaj.zone
Yes, agree - domestic flights are the only ones you can control. But note you can opt-out at least on the US TSA side and boarding side even on international flights.
Replying to @NekoKoneko@lemmy.world
Unfortunately I wasn’t born with enough privilege to attempt to question a tsa agent. I get randomly selected enough as it is.
Replying to @bantering@lemmy.zip
I empathize and if that’s the way you feel, that’s understandable.
But I’d recommend to try it, even if your feelings suggest it’s just going to make trouble. As noted, there is an explicit non-discretionary optional policy for it and TSA agents - even if they’re trying to make the photo seem like the only choice - get a ton of opt-outs every day and it’s probably not going to (for the moment) trigger retribution. (I say this traveling with non-white people and never seeing them get secondarily screened later in the process, or more so than me anyway - but yes, I’m speaking from a place of privilege so could be wrong.)
Replying to @NekoKoneko@lemmy.world
As I witnessed today, even just stating that you are opting out is not enough. You must ensure, of your own accord, that the camera is not directed at you when you approach the TSA agent, or else it will automatically photograph you.
I’ve also had a TSA agent tell me that I need to tell them I opt out before handing them my ID. This is obviously problematic but that’s just how this shit works today.
Replying to @tatterdemalion@programming.dev
I wear an N95 mask and only remove it after opting out. Yes, good advice for sure.
Replying to @tatterdemalion@programming.dev
Ever since they introduced the facial recognition software I have opted out. I always approach the station at an angle if possible or with my passport between the camera and my face if not. Then when thy ask me to step in front of the camera a simple “No, thank you” has always worked. Polite yet firm and they hand me back my passport and away I go. It’s pretty much always faster.
Every so often you get a dickhead that makes a show of it taking longer to verifying it by their own eyeballs.
That being said, if you a flying internationally anymore, your picture at least will be taken when you enter.
Replying to @NekoKoneko@lemmy.world
But now if you do scan you get a brand new no touch Id line that’s even shorter.
Replying to @Lemming6969@lemmy.world
So far that isn’t the case and I’ve flown a lot recently. But yeah, I’m as pessimistic as you are about the future - I won’t be surprised when (not if) they do this.